Commentary

Forcing hoarders to conquer clutter


 

Drs. Jamie Feusner and Sanjaya Saxena offer valuable strategies for treating compulsive hoarding disorder (Current Psychiatry, March 2005),

Encouraging these patients to regularly have visitors over to their houses also can be extremely therapeutic. This approach works on several levels:

  • Patients would be embarrassed to have company see a messy home, so they will clean frantically before the visit.
  • To avoid future all-night clean-ups, they will be motivated to prevent clutter from accumulating day-to-day.
  • Social interaction with visitors provides support that reduces some causes of hoarding.

These visits force patients to be accountable and confront denial, much as Alcoholics Anonymous does for patients with alcohol use disorders. Even if the clutter is displaced to closets—as is often the case—it is still a major step forward. This approach requires a strong therapeutic alliance, but patients will receive positive reinforcement that sustains their progress.

Isaac Steven Herschkopf, MD
Clinical instructor
Department of psychiatry
New York University School of Medicine
New York, NY

Recommended Reading

Technology Extends Reach of the Bully
MDedge Psychiatry
Electronic Prescribing Projects Start to Take Hold : The aim of new federal standards is to make it easier and more attractive to use the technology.
MDedge Psychiatry
DATA WATCH
MDedge Psychiatry
New Federal Law Expected to Limit Class-Action Lawsuits
MDedge Psychiatry
On-Call Emergency Care Issue Revives Debate
MDedge Psychiatry
West Virginia Sees Malpractice Improvement After Reform
MDedge Psychiatry
Physicians: Medicare Formula Is Priority in Reform
MDedge Psychiatry
California Health Care Purchaser Rejects HSAs : CalPERS' chief says dropping hospitals, physician practices will save millions for members, taxpayers.
MDedge Psychiatry
Psychiatrists Responding to Tsunami Tragedy : Disaster Psychiatry Outreach hopes to train local leaders in Sri Lanka to work as counselors.
MDedge Psychiatry
Raising a Child With Special Needs
MDedge Psychiatry