Medicolegal Issues

Smoking allowed: Is hospital policy a liability risk?

Author and Disclosure Information

 

References

Dear Dr. Mossman:

I work at a state mental hospital where all patients are adults who are court-committed, and at least 75% of them smoke. The hospital allows smoking in part of the only outdoor area where patients—smokers and nonsmokers—may go while in our most restrictive treatment phase. Patients come to us after spending at least 2 weeks in nonsmoking facilities where smokers receive nicotine replacement therapy. If patients want to smoke but have no money, in the past our hospital provided “unit cigarettes.”

In my state, a court commitment means the patient lacks the capacity to make decisions about psychiatric care. Of course nicotine is a psychoactive drug. If a patient starts smoking while in our care, would the hospital be liable for health-related expenses the patient may later incur?—Submitted by “Dr. A”

Speaking as one colleague to another about malpractice liability, letting psychiatric patients smoke is not breaching the standard of care toward smoking patients. But you care for nonsmoking patients as well, and other types of liability besides malpractice exist.

Doctors have moral duties for lots of things we can’t be sued for. Dr. A is right to be concerned. To explain, we’ll look at:

  • changes in attitudes about smoking
  • the link between smoking and mental illness
  • smoking bans in psychiatric facilities
  • malpractice potential
  • other issues Dr. A’s hospital should consider, such as offering patients assistance with smoking cessation.

Changing attitudes about smoking

Thirty years ago, doctors smoked during medical meetings, and smoking on airplanes and in public was commonplace. I worked at an adolescent inpatient unit, and line staff carried lighters. We thought lighting kids’ cigarettes was a legitimate way to establish rapport. Times and attitudes have changed. No hospital condones smoking these days, let alone smoking by minor patients. Since the Surgeon General first declared in 1964 that smoking was hazardous, U.S. adult smoking rates have dropped from 42% to under 20%.1

In the early 1990s, California issued the first statewide ban on smoking in work-places, including bars and restaurants.2 Nearly 3,000 state or local jurisdictions require workplaces and/or commercial establishments to be smoke-free.3 Recently, the legislature in Virginia—a major tobacco-producing state—voted to prohibit smoking in restaurants,4 and many other state governments are considering smoking bans. Smoking bans are intended to protect nonsmokers—especially children—from risks of secondhand smoke,5 but they also discourage individuals from taking up the habit6 and encourage smokers to quit.7

DO YOU HAVE A QUESTION ABOUT POSSIBLE LIABILITY?
  • Submit your malpractice-related questions to Dr. Mossman at douglas.mossman@dowdenhealth.com.
  • Include your name, address, and practice location. If your question is chosen for publication, your name can be withheld by request.
  • All readers who submit questions will be included in quarterly drawings for a $50 gift certificate for Professional Risk Management Services, Inc’s online marketplace of risk management publications and resources (www.prms.com).

Smoking and mental illness

Persons with serious psychiatric disorders have smoking rates 2 to 3 times higher than those of the general population.8,9 As Dr. A notes, nicotine is a psychoactive drug. Smoking may be a genuine—although ultimately unhealthy—form of self-medication and may have positive psychological effects, such as antidepressant activity for many mentally ill persons.10,11 The Joint Commission on Accreditation of Healthcare Organizations banned smoking in hospitals in 1992 but made an exception for psychiatric units. Out of sympathy for patients and concern about what could happen when they are deprived of a substance they intensely crave, many psychiatric wards continue to accommodate smokers.12

What some institutions have done

An increasing number of psychiatric facilities have instituted or are considering bans on smoking.13 The first psychiatric smoking bans were implemented despite fears that patient violence would increase and opposition from hospital employees—a group that often includes smokers. Experience shows that although not all smoking bans are successful or problem-free,14 they usually cause fewer problems than anticipated. We also know what factors help make smoke-free programs successful (Table).15

Table

Smoke-free plans that work: How to clear the air

• Take time—more than 6 months—to plan smoke-free initiatives
Supply patient and staff smokers with nicotine replacement therapy
Present clear, consistent, visible leadership
Encourage cohesive teamwork
Provide extensive education and training for staff
Reduce staff smoking rates
Offer programs and education to promote smoking cessation among staff members
Enforce nonsmoking policies
Source: Adapted from reference 15

Aggression, seclusion, discharges against medical advice, and “prn” medication use do not increase after smoking bans,5,16,17 and many patients experience health benefits.18 After discharge, however, most patients resume tobacco use.11,19,20

Pages

Recommended Reading

Judicious Use of Bipolar Diagnosis Is Advised
MDedge Psychiatry
Statins May Cut AD Risk, Even in ApoE4 Carriers
MDedge Psychiatry
Cerebral Injury in Dementia is Tied to Diabetes
MDedge Psychiatry
Cash Incentives Encourage Smoking Cessation
MDedge Psychiatry
Internet-Based Substance Abuse Screening, Self-Help Come of Age
MDedge Psychiatry
Policy & Practice
MDedge Psychiatry
Medical School Leaders Are Poised for Challenges
MDedge Psychiatry
FYI
MDedge Psychiatry
Boost Your Bargaining Power
MDedge Psychiatry
What to do when a patient makes you angry
MDedge Psychiatry