Evidence-Based Reviews

Beware ictal activity that mimics psychiatric illness

Author and Disclosure Information

How to detect and halt nonconvulsive status epilepticus.


 

References

Nonconvulsive status epilepticus (NCSE) is marked by neurobehavioral disturbances that resemble primary psychiatric disorders. Mistaken diagnosis and delayed treatment increase the risk of neurologic damage, so recognizing NCSE symptoms early is important.

To help you make a timely diagnosis, this article describes:

  • neuropsychiatric manifestations of NCSE
  • how to narrow the differential diagnosis by reviewing clinical symptoms and using electroencephalography (EEG)
  • techniques used to rapidly halt ictal activity.

Box

Status epilepticus: Risk of death, brain injury from nonconvulsive forms

Status epilepticus (SE) is an acute medical emergency. Both forms—convulsive (CSE) and nonconvulsive (NCSE)—require early recognition and treatment. In the United States, 60 SE cases occur per 100,000 population/year, with mortality rates of 20% in adults and 38% in the elderly.1,2

Mortality risk. Data suggest patients with NCSE are unlikely to die unless NCSE co-occurs with CSE or severe medical illness such as delirium or acute complications. Mortality risk does not appear linked with a type of EEG discharge.3

Neurologic injury risk. Prolonged NCSE may cause permanent neurologic damage.4 Transient memory impairment has been reported after cessation of complex partial status epilepticus (CPSE).5 CPSE also has resulted in prolonged neurologic deficits, although concomitant medical illnesses might have contributed to the deficits.6 In one study, some patients gradually returned to baseline cognitive function after CPSE stopped, but they were not tested with standardized neuropsychological tools.7

No significant postictal memory impairment was observed on neuropsychological testing in patients with NCSE of frontal origin.8 A >5-year follow-up study of absence status epilepticus (ASE) found no evidence of long-term cognitive or behavioral decline, even though most patients had recurrent ASE.9 Similarly, no long-term sequelae were seen in patients with ASE.10,11

Triggers, neurologic symptoms

NCSE is an acute but treatable medical emergency that calls for assessing and supporting cardiac and respiratory function, monitoring vital signs, temperature reduction, and fluid replacement. Prognosis is usually good unless NCSE is associated with a serious medical illness (Box).1-11

Many metabolic, neurologic, pharmacologic, and medical abnormalities can precipitate NCSE (Table 1). The most common causes are hypoxia/anoxia, stroke, infection, subtherapeutic antiepileptic levels, alcohol and benzodiazepine intoxication/withdrawal, and metabolic abnormalities.4,7,10,12

NCSE manifests as absence status epilepticus (ASE) or complex partial status epilepticus (CPSE). A generally accepted diagnostic definition is ≥30 minutes of behavioral change from baseline, with diagnostic EEG findings.4,13 EEG is indispensable because the clinical manifestations of NCSE are predominantly behavioral, with minimal or no motor activity.

Table 1

Clinical factors that may precipitate NCSE

MedicalRecent infection, hyperventilation, trauma, menstruation, pregnancy, renal dialysis, postoperative period, sleep deprivation
MetabolicHypoparathyroidism, renal failure, hyper/hyponatremia, hyper/hypoglycemia, hypocalcemia
NeurologicMental retardation, dementia, stroke
PharmacologicLow serum levels or abrupt discontinuation of anticonvulsants, alcohol intoxication/withdrawal, benzodiazepine withdrawal lithium and neuroleptic use, psychotropic overdose
Source : References 9,10,12,16
ASE, a primary generalized process, is characterized by confusion or diminished responsiveness; it may be associated with occasional blinking or other minor motor activity and can last for hours to days. It usually occurs in patients with known epilepsy, particularly absence seizures.

ASE is reported primarily in children, although de novo cases have been described in elderly patients with no history of epilepsy.10,14

CPSE is usually associated with a history of focal epilepsy and vascular disease. CPSE has a focal onset, with subsequent secondary generalization. Onset is usually temporal in origin but also can be extratemporal.

Patients with CPSE often cycle between an “epileptic twilight state” with confusion and complete unresponsiveness with stereotyped automatisms. It can present with marked behavioral fluctuation or a change in mental status and is generally followed by a prolonged postictal state.4,7,13-15 Several NCSE cases have occurred in patients with no history of seizures.9,10,16

Historically, CPSE was reported to be less common than ASE, but this misconception was most likely caused by failure to recognize CPSE’s clinical presentation and rapid generalization on EEG.7,15

Neuropsychiatric features

Patients with NCSE may be referred for evaluation of an array of behavioral changes commonly seen in psychiatric practice. The differential diagnosis is extensive (Table 2) and includes neurologic and medical conditions often associated with catatonic syndrome.17,18

In a retrospective study, Kaplan12 assessed clinical presentations and reasons for diagnostic delay in 23 adults eventually diagnosed with NCSE. Presenting symptoms included:

  • confusion, agitation, aggressive behavior
  • lethargy, mutism, verbal perseveration, echolalia
  • delirium, blinking, staring, chewing or picking behaviors
  • tremulousness or myoclonus
  • bizarre behavior (inappropriate laughing, crying, or singing)
  • rigidity with waxy flexibility
  • delusions, hallucinations.
Clinicians mistook hallucinations and mood lability for a primary psychiatric condition in 7 patients, presumed catalepsy was psychogenic in 3 patients, and thought obtundation was caused by alcohol or drug intoxication in 4 cases.

A prospective study of 22 patients with NCSE found that 7 had a history of psychotic depression, schizophrenia, self-mutilation, bipolar disorder, or episodic severe aggression; 12 of 18 with ASE had a history of epilepsy, and 3 of 4 with CPSE had experienced seizures associated with cerebrovascular accident, right cerebral embolus, and thiazide-induced hyponatremia, respectively.16

Pages

Recommended Reading

Play, Stress Management Combat Childhood PTSD
MDedge Psychiatry
Initial Focus on OCD May Ease Defiant Disorder : Results show patients must be open to engaging in exposure therapy for treatment to be effective.
MDedge Psychiatry
Survey: Teens Use Inhalants More, Worry About Risks Less
MDedge Psychiatry
Writing Wrongs: Treating Graphomotor Problems
MDedge Psychiatry
Clinical Capsules
MDedge Psychiatry
Survey Eyes Cycle of Sexual Abusers and Victims
MDedge Psychiatry
One-Third of U.S. Girls Sexually Active by Age 15, CDC Says
MDedge Psychiatry
ADHD Treatment Less Risky Than Nontreatment : The risk for substance abuse in untreated patients is 75%, compared with 25% in treated patients.
MDedge Psychiatry
Study Strongly Links Adenotonsillectomy With Improved ADHD
MDedge Psychiatry
Don't Misdiagnose Hydrocephalus as Dementia
MDedge Psychiatry