Commentary

Provide patients asylum


 

References

It is refreshing to see Dr. Nasrallah challenge the notion that deinstitutionalization benefits our patients. Discharge planning for our schizophrenic patients is the biggest obstacle my colleagues and I face.

We all have similar stories of managing an acute psychotic episode only to have the patient return within a few weeks after not taking prescribed medication or suffering the wraths of homelessness and poverty. Most of our schizophrenic patients lack necessary psychosocial and occupational necessities that would give them the best hope for recovery.

In an institution compliance is addressed, shelter is provided, and patients can hold a job, which gives them self-confidence and allows them to contribute economically to society. Also in an institution we can address patients’ comorbid substance use, which would increase the efficacy of our biologically based therapies. If we do not stand up for our patients they will continue to be victimized on the streets and many eventually will be institutionalized in the correctional system.

The dictionary defines asylum as “a place of retreat and security.” Shouldn’t psychiatrists fight for security in our patients’ insecure lives?

Jesse Rhoads, DO
Resident
Ohio State University, Columbus

Recommended Reading

Urge Parents to Guide Teens' Cell Phone Use
MDedge Psychiatry
Bullies and Victims Feel Worthless, Sad, Unsafe
MDedge Psychiatry
Cyberbullying Is Common, Psychologically Damaging
MDedge Psychiatry
Responsiveness to External Cues Tied to Obesity
MDedge Psychiatry
Wheeled Sports: Benefits Are Long Term
MDedge Psychiatry
Secrecy, Nondisclosure in Adolescence Explored : New research shows 'stronger manifestation of the darker side of secrecy' among younger teenagers.
MDedge Psychiatry
Pain Tx Can Improve Cognition, Lift Depression : To get handle on extent of patients' pain, ask them direct questions and pay attention to nonverbal cues.
MDedge Psychiatry
Stoicism, Safety Concerns May Limit Pain Management
MDedge Psychiatry
Use Caution When Prescribing for Insomnia
MDedge Psychiatry
Older Women Face Higher Depression Burden
MDedge Psychiatry