Commentary

Schizophrenia: no mood disorder


 

Bipolar disorder and schizophrenia are two distinct disorders (Current Psychiatry, March 2006). True, many bipolar patients are misdiagnosed as having schizophrenia, and some patients have overlapping symptoms of both disorders. Many patients with schizophrenia, however, have chronic persistent psychosis and negative symptoms with no mood disorder.

Also, how can the authors say that misdiagnosing bipolar disorder as schizophrenia would unnecessarily expose patients to antipsychotics instead of needed mood stabilizers? Many atypical antipsychotics work as mood stabilizers, sometimes more effectively than lithium, divalproex, or other old standards. It sounded like the authors were turning back the clock to when many bipolar patients were misdiagnosed with schizophrenia and placed on long-term haloperidol or another conventional antipsychotic.

Anthony Green, MD
Aberdeen, NJ

Recommended Reading

School-Based Project Improves Girls' Coping Skills
MDedge Psychiatry
Antidepressants Raise Suicide Risk, Data Show
MDedge Psychiatry
Depression Contagion: Parents Can Affect Children
MDedge Psychiatry
Children With Anxiety, Depression More Likely to Use Ecstasy
MDedge Psychiatry
Tool Helps Spot Bipolar Prodrome in Children : Questionnaire asks patients to rate 39 symptoms that can emerge before the first manic episode.
MDedge Psychiatry
Dearth of Evidence in Guiding Tx Of Bipolar Depression in Teens
MDedge Psychiatry
Quetiapine May Help Manage Depression in Bipolar Adolescents
MDedge Psychiatry
Children Suffer Long Term When Parent Has a Stroke
MDedge Psychiatry
Olfactory Deficits May Be a Signal for Early Psychosis
MDedge Psychiatry
Lamotrigine Effective Add-On for Seizures : Adjunctive treatment reduces frequency of primary generalized tonic-clonic seizures.
MDedge Psychiatry